Join CafeMom Today! Autism Spectrum Disorder: Treatments: HBOT Miracle, Junk Science, Both?

Friday, October 17, 2008

HBOT Miracle, Junk Science, Both?

From CBS 4 in Denver. Report on the benefits of HBOT for autistic children.


Miracle or Junk Science? http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/?p=249

All signs point to a guy named Dan Rossignol. Dr. Rossignol is apparently into every form of autism crankery, including mercury poisoning, mitochondrial dysfunction, and oxidative stress (although I can’t imagine that increased PaO2 is an effective treatment for “oxidative stress”). After spending a few minutes looking through his web-based material, I’m starting to think that this guy can give the Geier’s a run for their money.

True to form, Rossignol is a “pioneer” and a “maverick”. He goes where legitimate clinicians haven’t dared. Based on an implausible hypothesis, he (apparently) subjects autistic children to potentially dangerous hyperbaric oxygen therapy. He has published his ideas in the crank-magnet “Medical Hypotheses”, and in BMC Pediatrics, a journal devoted to rapid, “flexible” publication.

Even if his data were to support his nonsensical hypothesis (again, increased O2 to treat oxidative stress??), should we believe it?

Well, someone does, and that someone apparently sells hyperbaric therapy, and not just for autism. They also treat Lyme disease, multiple sclerosis, and cerebral palsy—and anything else you can spell. The site does, however, have a very small Quack Miranda Warning on the left sidebar.

1 comment:

Unknown said...

You sir, are a nut who should look at the people who have been helped with HBOT, and there are hundreds of thousands of people, young and old. For you to condem HBOT because of one person, is WRONG, Narrow minded and STUPID, It makes you no better than the person you are condeming. I Know HBOT first hand,ups and downs, I walk the path with personal knowledge. YOU DO NOT> shut up and get off you virtual soapbox. If you have no first hand experience, step aside.

Labels

420 (1) AABA (1) AAT (9) ABA (27) Abilify (2) Acamprosate (1) Acupuncture (2) Adeli Suit Therapy (1) AEIOU Early Intervention (1) Afinitor (1) AIT (3) Algae (1) Alzheimer's Drugs (2) Amantadine (1) Amino Acids (1) AMMT (1) Anat Baniel Method (1) Animal Assisted Therapy (15) Anti psychotics (2) Anti-convulsants (2) Anti-fungal therapy (1) Anti-yeast therapy (2) Antibiotics (1) Antidepressants (7) Antioxidants (1) Antipsychotics (2) Applied Affectionate Behavior Analysis (1) Applied Behavioral Analysis (26) Arbaclofen (1) Art Therapy (9) Assistive Technology (18) Athletics (1) Audio-Visual Entrainment (1) Auditory Integration Training (3) Auditory Motor Mapping Training (1) Augmentative Communication (17) Autism (7) Autism Clinical Trials Network (1) Autism Fun (2) Autism Treatments are Expensive (11) Autism360 (1) AVE (1) Baclofen (2) Bacteroides (1) BCAAs (1) BDNF (1) benzodiazepine (1) Better Diagnosis (1) Biofeedback (9) Biomedical Treatments (4) Brain Plasticity (1) Branched Chain Amino Acids (1) Bumetanide (1) Bumex (1) Burinex (1) Buspar (1) Buspirone Hydrochloride (1) Cannabis (7) Cerebral Folate Deficiency (1) Character Therapy (1) Cheerleading (1) Chelation (4) Chewing Gum (1) Chiropractic (1) Cholesterol (1) CLM (1) clonazepam (1) Coffee (1) Communication Devices (16) Competent Learner Model (1) Computers (12) Contrarian (1) Cord Blood (1) Costs of Treatment (17) CranioSacral Therapy (1) Cutting-Edge Therapies (2) Cybertherapy (1) D-Cycloserine (1) DAN (5) Dance (1) DATS (2) DCS (1) DEFEAT AUTISM NOW (6) Detecting Autism (1) Detox (1) Developmental Individual Difference Relationship Model (3) Diagnosing Autism (1) Diet (6) DIR (5) Disco (1) Discrete Affectionate Trials (1) Discrete Trial Training (4) DNA (1) Dolphin Dome (1) Dolphin Therapy (8) Drugs (34) DTT (5) DynaVox (14) Early Intensive Behavioural Intervention (1) ECLIPSE Model (1) Ecstasy (MDMA) (1) EEG Biofeedback (7) EIBI (1) Elephant therapy (1) Enzyme (1) Epigenetics (3) Epilepsy (5) Epsom Salts (2) Equine Therapy (10) Face Recognition (1) Facial Reflexology (1) Fatty Acids (2) Fish Oil (2) Floor Time (8) Floortime (7) Fluoxetine (1) fMRI (1) Folic Acid (2) Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (1) Games (3) Gene Therapy (4) Genome Sequencing (1) Glutathione (1) Grace (1) HBOT (16) Hippotherapy (7) Hormones (1) Horse Therapy (11) Hydration (1) Hyperbaric Oxygen (16) Hyperinsulinemia (1) Hypnosis (1) Hypnotherapy (1) iCommunicate (1) Immunotherapy (1) Insurance Coverage for Autism (20) Intravenous immunoglobulin (1) iontoporation (1) iPad (9) iPhone (7) iPod (9) iPrompts (1) IVIG (1) Law of Attraction (1) LEGOS (2) Leucovorin (1) Leupeptin (1) Lexapro (escitalopram) (2) Life Skills (3) Lovass (1) Lupron (5) Marinol (1) Masgutova method (1) Masgutova Neuro-sensory-motor Reflex Integration (2) Massage (1) MB12 (4) Medical Marijuana (6) Medications (9) Meditation (1) Mendability (1) Methyl-B12 (4) Methylcobalamin (2) Miracle Mineral Supplement (2) Misc (5) Mitochondrial Dysfunction (1) MMS (2) MnemeTherapy™ (1) MNRI (1) Music Therapy (6) N-Acetylcysteine (1) NAC (1) NAET (1) Namenda (1) Nasal Insulin (1) nasal spray (2) NATURAL ENVIRONMENT TRAINING (2) Natural Language Paradigm (1) Naturalistic Learning (2) NET (1) Netbook (1) Neurofeedback (9) Neuroliminal Training (2) NHE6 protein (1) Nicotine Patch (1) Nintendo (1) NLP (1) NT (2) Nutritional therapy (1) Occupational Therapy (1) Omega-3 (3) Online Autism Therapy (3) Optimize Strengthen Rejuvenate (3) OSR (4) Oxidative Stress Release (3) Oxytocin (2) P.L.A.Y. Project (1) Parasitic Worms (1) PECS (8) PEMF (1) Physical Therapy (1) Picture Exchange Communication System (8) Pilates (1) Pivotal Response Therapy (2) Play and Language for Autistic Youngsters (1) Pot (1) Probiotics (3) Proloquo2Go (1) Propranolol (1) Protease Inhibitor (1) Prozac (2) PRT (1) Pulsed Electromagnetic Field Therapy (1) Rapamycin (1) Rapid Prompting Method (1) Reducing Oxidative Stress (1) Respen-A (2) Response Interruption/Redirection (1) RIR (1) Risperdal (1) Risperidone (4) Ritalin (1) Robots (3) RPM (1) rTMS (1) SAVE (1) Scams (1) SCERTS (1) Screening for Autism (1) Secretin (1) Seizures (4) Sensori-motor Auditory Visual Education (1) Sensory Enrichment Therapy (1) Sensory Integration Therapy (5) Service Dogs (5) Shank3 Protein (1) Shaping and Chaining (1) Sign Language (1) Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms (1) SIT (1) Skateboarding (1) SNP (1) Social Communication Emotional Regulation Transitional Support (1) Software (4) Speaker Immersion (1) Speech-Language Therapy (2) Spirulina (1) Sports (1) SSRIs (1) Stem Cells (6) Stimulants (1) Studies (1) STX209 (2) Supplements (7) Surfing (2) Taekwondo (1) Tangible Time Management (1) TEACCH (5) Telehealth (1) Telemedicine (1) THC (4) The Secret (1) Therapeutic Horseback Riding (9) Therapy Dogs (1) THR (7) Time Timer (2) Timothy Syndrome (1) TMS (2) Toxic (1) Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (2) Transgenic Mouse Model (1) Vanspar (1) VB (3) Verbal Behavior Approach (1) Verbal Behavior Model (3) Video Games (4) Video Modeling (1) Vitamin B6 [Pyridoxine] (1) Vitamins (6) Wii (1) Wrestling (1) Xbox Kinect (2) Yoga (7) Zinc (1)

Add This ...

Bookmark and Share